Homemade Pizza inspired by Outlander book The Fiery Cross

Roger & Bree's Homemade Pizza from TFC for Valentine's Day

"Pizza," he said.

She blinked, then laughed.  It was one of their games; taking turns to think of things they missed from the other time, the time before -- or after, depending on how you looked at it.

"Coke," she said promptly.  "I think I could maybe do pizza -- but what good is pizza without Coca-Cola?"

"Pizza with beer is perfectly fine," he assured her.  "And we can have beer -- not that Lizzie's homemade hell-brew is quite on par with MacEwan's Lager, yet.  But you really think you could make pizza?"

"Don't see why not."  She nibbled at the cheese, frowning.  "this wouldn't do" -- she brandished the yellowish remnant, then popped it in her mouth -- "too strong-flavoured.  But I think..." she paused to chew and swallow, then washed it down with a long drink of rough cider.

"Come to think of it, this would go pretty well with pizza." She lowered the leather bottle and licked the last sweet, semi-alcoholic drops from her lips.  "But the cheese -- I think maybe sheep's cheese would do.  Da brought some from Salem last time he went there.  I'll ask him to get some more and see how it melts."

She squinted against the bright, pale sun, calculating.

"Mama's got plenty of dried tomatoes, and tons of garlic.  I know she has basil don't know about the oregano, but I could do without that. And crust -- "  She waved a dismissive hand.  "Flour, water, and lard, nothing to it."

Diana Gabaldon, The Fiery Cross (Chapter 20)

After last week's excerpt, when we left Roger dragging Brianna out the back door of the big house to bring an end to that stramash she had with Mrs Bug, I felt the need to inject a little love back into the page for Valentine's Day!

And so here we find R&B taking a break from their morning's shooting lessons -- a quiet moment, not terribly full of amorous feeling (especially when it comes to DG) -- but still one of my favourites between them.  After all, they don't have a lot of free time to wax lyrical about love; they're a little busy surviving the backwoods of Colonial America, thanks very much!

Dauco seeds, a MacGyvered pizza, three or four precious gems and a half decent pint of lager...that's just a partial list of what these 20th Century kids need to get along in their New World.

dried-tomatoes-mushrooms copy

As for my adaptation of the pizza Roger & Bree dreamed up over their lunch of ham and piccalilli, I tried to stay as true to DG's words as I could.  At least for the first pie.

I spread some basil pesto on the crust and dotted it with an umami-filled puree made from the sundried tomatoes and Porcini mushrooms you see above.  I soaked them in boiling water (and a bit of sherry) for 20 minutes, then drained and squeezed the extra water out of them before chopping finely.  I have no doubt Claire would have had some dried mushrooms around -- probably not Porcinis -- but you have to use what you've got, right?  :)

Also on top was some thinly sliced raw garlic, cured sausage, onion and goat's cheese.

Pretty modern sounding for 1770, eh?  But I promise you it's as authentic as an 18th Century pizza can be...

homemade pizza pesto

I went my own way with the second pizza, and opted for a tomato base followed by a mix of mozzarella and parmesan.

Next on were some eggplant slices that I had earlier dredged in seasoned flour and pan fried, as well as red peppers, roasted garlic, anchovies (for my Englishman) and a few dollops of leftover pesto.

tomato pizza copy

The crust recipe is one I adapted from Saveur.com -- I've used for over a year now, and it's the best homemade crust I've found in an (almost) lifelong search.

Happy Valentine's Day to everyone out there.  Keep it real.

Homemade Pizza

Show/Hide Comments


13 Feb 2012 - 10:21am


YUMMY, going to try these this week. I don't often make any dough by hand these days, I throw it in the breadmaker and it comes out after an hour mixed , kneaded, smooth, doubled in size and ready to go.( And I have a fab dough rising setting on my oven as well.) The hour for the dough in the breadmaker is really useful as the kids love making pizza as well so we use that time to prepare all the toppings and the rest of dinner, plus the fact that my kitchen is so small there isn't enough room to do both things at once.n I need/want a huge kitchen with 8 of us (was 9 but no. 1 son moved out now) especially now as my girls love to cook and especially we all love baking but theres only room for 1 of them with me at a time. Sorry Theresa got carried away there lol.n :-)


Sounds like a wonderful, if just a bit small, homemade kitchen, Lesley!

13 Feb 2012 - 1:52pm

Lee Ann

I was just listening to that passage from FC on my iPod! It left me thinking about making pizza their way too! And this is making me want to fire up my pizza stone! Thanks! I'm going to try your crust recipe too!

13 Feb 2012 - 6:50pm


Yum! I already have Valentine's day planned out, but maybe it could be in a clover for St. Pat's Day! Thanks for sharing.


Love the shamrock pizza idea, Aaron!

13 Feb 2012 - 7:02pm


Loved this bit in the books and love the recipe and pictures. This is such a great blog, it's always making me hungry. haha


Then I guess it`s time to get cookin, eh JustHeather? ;)

13 Feb 2012 - 11:16pm


this looks delicious! i actually have gluten free pizza crust! i think i'll have to try this one this week....do you make the sauce from scratch?


I do make my own basic tomato sauce, but sauce you see in these pictures is actually a mixture of tomato paste and , which turned out to be a really nice base. I have also been known to buy a can of pizza sauce to save time...

14 Feb 2012 - 7:30am



14 Feb 2012 - 5:31pm

Kat from Jersey

Mmm, sounds yummy! And, as far as the missing Coke goes, if anyone could have figured out the recipe for Coca-Cola, it would be Bree.


It seems she's finally found an 18th C drink she can stomach, though! Whisky's a no, as is ale...thank goodness for cider!

19 Feb 2012 - 7:42pm

Shana Jensen

My kids always want to help out in the kitchen and many of your recipes are family friendly - They don't just want to open and box and turn on the oven, they want to dig-in and get their hands dirty. Pizza dough, Tomato Sauce - Oh yeah. I'm in.


I'm so glad you think so, Shana! I was always underfoot in the kitchen as a little one...I have my Mom to thank for my love of food.

06 May 2012 - 10:41pm


I have been making this every Sunday night and it turns out perfectly! Thanks so much for such a well thought out site with some great ideas. I am from Canada but have been living temporarily in South America with my husband. Where we live, a lot of familiar ingredients are sparse (hmm, I can probably relate to Bree, at least a little!), so this pizza is perfect because I can make the dough and then use whatever toppings I can find. Lately my husband's favourite pizza has been with a homemade marinara sauce, leftover steak and parmesan topping :)


How wonderful...and thank you for letting me know how much you enjoy it! Comfort food from home never goes amiss...Theresa

17 Jun 2012 - 8:12pm

Lisa (Book Blab)

Cute! I love the excerpt and the heart shape!

Add new comment

You might also be interested in